Honest comparison with sources. We're not going to trash anyone. If a competitor is a better fit for your use-case, we'll tell you.
| Feature | CardGradeCheck | PreGradeCards | SnapGradeAI | CardGrade.io | TCGrader |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free scan volume | Unlimited, no signup | 1/day free, paid tiers | 3/day free | 1/day free | Freemium with cap |
| Signup required | No | Yes for paid | Yes for >3 | Yes for paid | Yes |
| Graders predicted | PSA + BGS + CGC + SGC + TAG | PSA only | PSA only | PSA only | PSA only |
| Sub-grades (BGS) | Yes — all four axes | No | No | No | No |
| Dataset size claimed | Live (growing from launch) | 1.2M analyzed* | Not disclosed | Not disclosed | Not disclosed |
| Accuracy claim | Live-updated public dashboard | 89% stated* | Not disclosed | Not disclosed | Not disclosed |
| Public methodology | Yes — full capping rules | Partial (high-level) | No | No | No |
| Public accuracy dashboard | Yes — live-updated, N shown | No | No | No | No |
| Cost calculator per card | Yes — per grader, per tier | No | No | No | No |
| eBay sold-comps shown | Yes (via EPN API) | Partial | No | No | No |
| Multi-angle photo flow | Front + back + 2 corners | Single photo | Single photo | Single photo | Single photo |
| Mobile camera capture | In-browser with framing overlay | File picker | File picker | File picker | File picker |
| PDF export of result | Yes | Partial (paid) | No | No | No |
| Shareable result URL | Yes — permanent /verify/<id> | No | No | No | No |
| Feedback form on result | Yes — 3-click + optional cert# | No | No | No | No |
| Mobile Lighthouse score | Target ≥95 | ~76 avg** | ~70** | ~82** | ~68** |
* Source: PreGradeCards homepage, 2026-11-14 snapshot.
** Measured via Lighthouse-CLI on homepage, 2026-11-14. Methodology: 4G throttling, mobile viewport, cold load.
"Not disclosed" = we couldn't find a public source. If a competitor adds a feature or a public claim, we'll update this page.
Every competitor caps the free tier (1-3 scans/day) or requires signup for anything. We don't. If you want to scan 40 cards from a bulk lot, you can — no account, no email required.
We output PSA, BGS (with sub-grades), CGC, SGC, and TAG predictions from a single scan. Every competitor on this list predicts PSA only. If you're deciding between BGS and PSA because BGS only has Express open as of October 2026, seeing both predictions side-by-side changes the decision.
Our /methodology page lists every capping rule we apply. Centering 65/35 → PSA 8 max. One bad corner → caps that axis. Crease → PSA 5 max. We're the only tool that publishes them. If you disagree with a grade, you can check our work.
/accuracy is live-updated nightly from feedback-form submissions + cert-lookup cross-validation. Current numbers, sample size, trend over time — all public. Competitors publish a single accuracy number (sometimes) with no sample size.
Our calculator takes your raw card value + AI-predicted grade + PSA tier + resale venue and gives you a break-even price, a 3x ROI threshold, and an honest "don't grade this" warning when the math doesn't work. No competitor ships this.
Our mobile flow opens the rear camera directly with a guided-framing overlay (rule-of-thirds + border detection). Every competitor uses the file picker.
Every scan gets a permanent, tamper-evident link. Share your result on Reddit or Discord without screenshots. Competitors don't offer this.
PreGradeCards states they've analyzed ~1.2M cards. We're starting from a 300-card launch accuracy set. Dataset depth compounds: more scans → more edge-cases seen → better model calibration.
What this means for you: if you're scanning a card from an obscure Pokemon set (Japanese Neo era, promo overprints, error-card variants) and we return low confidence, PreGradeCards may have seen more examples. We'll close this gap through our feedback-loop + aggressive dataset growth — our /accuracy page will show you when.
PreGradeCards, SnapGradeAI, and CardGrade.io have been mentioned in r/PokemonTCG and collector Discords for 6+ months. We're new. If you want a tool your collector-friends have already heard of, that matters.
What this means for you: nothing, unless you're risk-averse to new tools. Our scans are free and anonymous — try us alongside a competitor on the same card and compare results.
More third-party review videos exist for the older tools. We're building ours. Zero search results on YouTube for "CardGradeCheck review" is honest; faking social proof is not something we'll do.
Published commitments. If we miss, /changelog will log it.
Honest decision guide. No hedging.
This is the honest answer. We think most collectors will land on us for most scans, but there are legit reasons to use another tool, and we're not going to pretend otherwise.