How to Submit Cards to PSA: Complete Step-by-Step Guide 2026
Submitting cards to PSA for the first time can feel overwhelming — membership tiers, service levels, packaging requirements, and shipping logistics. This guide walks you through every step from account creation to getting your slabs back.
- Before You Start: Pre-Screening Your Cards
- Step 1: Create a PSA Account and Choose a Membership
- Step 2: Choose Your Service Level
- Step 3: Fill Out Your Submission Form
- Step 4: Package Your Cards Properly
- Step 5: Ship to PSA
- Step 6: Track Your Order
- Step 7: Receiving Your Graded Cards
- Pro Tips for First-Time Submitters
- Frequently Asked Questions
Before You Start: Pre-Screening Your Cards
The single biggest mistake first-time submitters make is sending cards that aren't worth grading. Grading fees, shipping, and insurance add up quickly, and a PSA 7 on a $20 card is a net loss every time.
Before you commit any money, evaluate each card honestly:
- Check the raw market value. Search recent sold listings on eBay for your card in raw (ungraded) condition. If it's under $50, Economy-tier grading probably won't produce a positive return unless you're confident in a PSA 9 or 10.
- Assess condition realistically. Look at centering, corners, edges, and surface under bright light. A card that looks "pretty good" often grades PSA 7-8, not 9-10.
- Use a pre-grading tool. Upload your card to CardGradeCheck for AI-powered analysis of centering, corners, edges, and surface. It gives you a grade estimate before you spend a dollar.
- Check population reports. If a card already has tens of thousands of PSA 10s, the graded premium is thin. Focus on cards where high grades are scarce.
Step 1: Create a PSA Account and Choose a Membership
You'll need a PSA Collectors Club membership to submit cards. Go to psacard.com, create an account, and select a membership tier.
PSA offers several membership levels. The basic tier is affordable and sufficient for most collectors submitting fewer than 50 cards per year. Higher tiers offer additional submission vouchers, reduced per-card fees, and faster service access.
When choosing a tier, consider how many cards you plan to submit over the next 12 months. If you're submitting 5-10 cards, the basic membership is fine. If you're submitting 50+, a higher tier may save money per card through included vouchers.
Tip: Group Submissions
If you only have 2-3 cards to grade, consider joining a group submission through a local card shop or online community. Group subs split shipping costs and sometimes get bulk pricing. The tradeoff is longer turnaround and less control over your submission.
Step 2: Choose Your Service Level
PSA offers multiple service tiers that balance cost against speed. The key factors are per-card grading fee, maximum declared value per card, and estimated turnaround time.
| Service Level | Approx. Cost/Card | Typical Turnaround | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Economy | ~$25 | Several months | Budget submissions, lower-value cards |
| Regular | ~$75 | 1-2 months | Mid-value cards, reasonable turnaround |
| Express | ~$150 | 1-2 weeks | Higher-value cards, time-sensitive sales |
| Super Express | ~$300+ | A few business days | High-value cards, urgent needs |
Pricing and turnaround times fluctuate. Always check PSA's current pricing page before submitting, as fees change periodically and turnaround estimates depend on their current submission volume.
Step 3: Fill Out Your Submission Form
Once logged in, create a new submission order on PSA's website. For each card, you'll need to provide:
- Card description — Set name, card number, year, and player/character name. Be as specific as possible. "2021 Pokemon Evolving Skies #203 Umbreon VMAX Alternate Art" is correct. "Umbreon card" is not.
- Declared value — Your honest estimate of the card's current market value. This determines insurance coverage and which service tiers are available.
- Service level — Selected from the tiers above.
- Special requests — Options like crossover grading (if sending a card already graded by another company) or special labels.
Double-check every entry. Errors in the card description can delay your order or result in incorrect labeling on the slab. PSA graders use your description to verify the card, so accuracy matters.
Step 4: Package Your Cards Properly
Improper packaging is one of the most avoidable reasons cards arrive damaged at PSA. Follow these steps exactly:
Materials You Need
- Penny sleeves (soft, inner sleeves)
- Semi-rigid card holders (Card Savers or equivalent) — PSA's preferred holder
- Blue painter's tape (not regular tape)
- A small to medium shipping box
- Bubble wrap or packing paper
- Rubber bands (optional, for grouping cards)
Step by step:
- Slide each card into a penny sleeve, open end first (so the card doesn't slide out).
- Insert the sleeved card into a semi-rigid card holder (Card Saver 1 is the standard).
- Use a small piece of blue painter's tape across the top of the Card Saver to keep the card from shifting during transit. Do not tape the card itself.
- Write the line number from your submission form on each Card Saver (matching the card to its form entry).
- Stack your Card Savers together and wrap with a rubber band or secure with tape.
- Place the stack inside the shipping box surrounded by bubble wrap or crumpled packing paper. The cards should not move when you shake the box.
- Print your PSA submission form and include it inside the box.
Step 5: Ship to PSA
Ship your package to the address provided on your submission confirmation. Key shipping guidelines:
- Use a tracked, insured shipping method. USPS Priority Mail with insurance is the most common choice for domestic US submissions. For international, use your country's tracked postal service or a courier like FedEx/UPS.
- Insure for declared value. Your shipping insurance should cover the total declared value of all cards in the package. If you're sending $2,000 worth of cards, insure for $2,000.
- Keep your tracking number. You'll want this to confirm delivery and for any disputes.
- Consider signature confirmation for high-value submissions.
PSA is located in Santa Ana, California. Factor in transit time from your location when planning your submission timeline.
Step 6: Track Your Order
Once PSA receives your package, your order status will update in your PSA account. The typical stages are:
- Received — PSA has your package.
- Research & ID — Staff are verifying your cards against the submission form.
- Grading — A grader is evaluating your cards.
- Assembly — Cards are being encapsulated in slabs.
- QA — Quality assurance check on the slabs.
- Shipped — Your graded cards are on their way back.
Be patient during the process, especially with Economy service. Checking your order status obsessively won't speed things up. PSA sends email notifications at key stages.
Step 7: Receiving Your Graded Cards
When your cards arrive, inspect them carefully:
- Verify that each slab matches the correct card and label information.
- Check for any damage to the slabs during shipping.
- Confirm the grades match what's shown in your online order.
- If anything is wrong, contact PSA's customer service immediately with photos.
Once verified, you can add your graded cards to your PSA Set Registry, list them for sale, or add them to your collection. Each slab has a unique certification number that buyers can verify on PSA's website.
Pro Tips for First-Time Submitters
- Start small. Submit 3-5 cards for your first order rather than 50. Learn the process with lower stakes.
- Pre-grade everything. Use CardGradeCheck to screen every card before submission. A $25 grading fee on a card that grades PSA 6 is money wasted.
- Handle cards with clean, dry hands or use cotton gloves. Fingerprints on the surface can cost you points.
- Don't clean your cards. Attempting to clean or polish a card almost always causes more damage than it fixes. Graders can spot cleaning artifacts.
- Photograph everything before sending. Take clear photos of each card's front, back, and any notable flaws before packaging. This protects you if there's a dispute about card condition upon return.
- Time your submissions strategically. Avoid submitting right after a major set release when PSA is flooded with volume. Turnaround times balloon during peak periods.
- Keep records. Track your submission costs, declared values, and final grades in a spreadsheet. Over time, this data helps you refine which cards are worth submitting and which tier to use.