Crack and Resubmit: Is It Worth Regrading Your Card?
You've got a PSA 9 that you think should be a 10, or a BGS 9.5 that could cross to PSA for more money. Cracking and resubmitting is a real strategy — but it's also a gamble. Here's how to know when the odds are in your favor.
What Is Crack and Resubmit?
"Crack and resubmit" (often shortened to "crack and resub") means physically opening a graded card's case (slab), removing the card, and sending it to a grading company for a new evaluation. The reasons collectors do this:
- Grade bump: Hoping a PSA 9 becomes a PSA 10 on resubmission
- Company crossover: Moving a card from BGS/CGC to PSA (or vice versa) for better resale value
- Label change: Updating from an older label style to a current one
- Correcting errors: If the original slab has incorrect card identification
The most common scenario is grade bumping — a collector gets a PSA 9 and believes the card deserves a 10. The appeal is obvious: the value difference between a 9 and 10 can be substantial. But the practice carries real risks that must be understood before you start cracking slabs.
When It's Worth Doing
Cracking and resubmitting makes financial sense only under specific conditions:
1. The Grade Premium Is Large
The value difference between your current grade and target grade must significantly exceed your total cost (grading fee + shipping + insurance + risk of a lower grade). If a PSA 9 sells for $100 and a PSA 10 sells for $500, there's $400 of potential upside. If the 9 sells for $100 and the 10 sells for $120, the math doesn't work.
2. You've Identified the Grade-Limiting Factor
If you know why the card got a 9 instead of a 10, you can assess whether resubmission is likely to help. If it's centering — which you can measure — and the centering is borderline 55/45, another grader might see it differently. If the centering is clearly 60/40, resubmission won't help. Use CardGradeCheck to measure centering and assess other factors.
3. The Issue Is Subjective
Surface and corner evaluations involve more judgment than centering. If you believe the grade-limiting factor was a borderline surface call (faint print lines, minor haze) rather than an objective measurement (centering ratio), there's a reasonable chance a different grader makes a different call.
4. Sub-Grades Tell the Story (BGS)
BGS sub-grades are your best friend for this decision. A BGS 9 with sub-grades of 9.5/9/9.5/9 tells you corners and surface are borderline. A BGS 9 with 9.5/9.5/9.5/8 tells you surface is the problem — and an 8 in any sub-category is a harder obstacle to overcome.
The Real Risks
Cracking a slab is a one-way door. Once you open it, the old grade is gone forever. The risks are real:
- Slab removal damage. Cracking a slab requires physical force. Even careful removal can introduce micro-scratches, corner dings, or edge damage. A card that was a legitimate 9 before removal might genuinely be an 8 after.
- Same grade return. The most common outcome of resubmission is getting the same grade back. You've spent money on grading and shipping to end up where you started.
- Sunk cost. Win or lose, you've spent $50-100+ on the resubmission process. This is money you don't get back even if the grade doesn't change.
- Time cost. Grading turnaround times mean your card is out of your possession for weeks or months. If market conditions change during that time, the value proposition could shift.
The Decision Framework
Before cracking any slab, run through this checklist:
- Calculate the upside. Target grade value minus current grade value = potential gain. Is this at least $100+ after grading costs?
- Assess probability. Based on the card's condition and grade-limiting factors, what's your honest success rate? Be conservative — 20% is more realistic than 50% for most PSA 9 to 10 attempts.
- Calculate expected value. (Success probability × potential gain) - (Failure probability × potential loss) - grading costs = expected value. If this number is negative, don't crack.
- Check condition with CardGradeCheck. After removing the card (or before, through the slab), use CardGradeCheck to get an independent assessment. If centering is the issue and it measures 58/42, don't bother.
- Consider the downside. Can you absorb the loss if the card comes back a grade lower? If losing $50-200 on a downgrade would sting, reconsider.
Example Calculation
Card: PSA 9 worth $200. PSA 10 would be worth $600.
Grading cost: ~$75 (Regular service + shipping)
Estimated success rate: 20% (conservative)
Expected value: (0.20 × $400 upside) - (0.05 × $100 downgrade loss) - $75 cost = $80 - $5 - $75 = $0
This is a break-even scenario. You'd need either a higher success probability or a larger premium to make it clearly worthwhile.
How to Safely Crack a Slab
If you decide to proceed, proper slab removal technique minimizes the risk of damaging your card:
- Work on a clean, soft surface. A microfiber cloth on a flat table is ideal. No crumbs, dust, or hard surfaces.
- Use a slab cracking tool or thin flathead screwdriver. Dedicated slab cracking tools are sold by hobby companies and are designed for the job. A thin flathead screwdriver also works.
- Find the seam. PSA slabs have a seam around the edge where the two halves meet. Insert your tool into this seam.
- Apply even, gentle pressure. Slowly pry the halves apart. Don't force it — work around the perimeter gradually. Rushing is how cards get scratched or dinged.
- Remove the card carefully. Once the slab is open, gently lift the card out. Don't slide it — lift it straight up. The label insert can sometimes stick to the card.
- Sleeve immediately. Put the card into a penny sleeve the moment it's out of the slab. Then into a Card Saver for resubmission.
- Inspect the card. Before submitting, examine the card under bright light. Check that the removal process didn't introduce any new damage.
Crossover Grading: BGS to PSA
Crossing cards from BGS to PSA is one of the more reliable crack-and-resubmit strategies because BGS sub-grades give you concrete data to work with.
BGS 9.5 to PSA 10: This is the most popular crossover. BGS 9.5 (Gem Mint) is roughly equivalent to PSA 10 (Gem Mint) in condition, but PSA 10s sell for more due to market preference. Success rates are generally good when sub-grades are 9.5+ across the board. If any sub-grade is a 9, especially centering, the risk increases.
BGS 10 (Pristine) to PSA 10: Very high success rate since BGS 10 represents a higher standard than PSA 10. However, the value gain may be smaller since BGS 10s already command strong prices.
CGC 9.5 to PSA 10: Similar logic to the BGS crossover. CGC 9.5 is roughly equivalent to PSA 10, and the price premium for PSA can make the crossover profitable.
Same Company Resubmission
Resubmitting a card to the same company that graded it originally (e.g., cracking a PSA 9 and sending it back to PSA) is the riskiest form of crack and resubmit. The same standards apply, and while a different grader may assess borderline calls differently, the odds of a significant grade change are lower than crossing companies.
This strategy makes most sense when:
- You believe the original grade was genuinely conservative (the card looks better than its grade suggests)
- The premium for one grade higher is very large (vintage chase cards)
- You're willing to accept that the most likely outcome is the same grade
For same-company resubmission, pre-screening with CardGradeCheck is especially important. If the tool's analysis aligns with the current grade, resubmission is unlikely to change the outcome. If the tool suggests the card should grade higher, you have additional data supporting the decision.